The topic of sustainable Christmas trees creeps up again and again: do they exist? Are you better off getting a real Christmas tree or an artificial one? What are the options?

We’re here to break all the sustainable Christmas tree-mania down. 

How sustainable are real Christmas trees?

Not much compares to the scent of a pine Christmas tree wafting through the house – even when you have to sweep up the needles every time you, the dog and your guests brush past.

The good news is Christmas trees are essentially a crop that we harvest. A six-foot tree typically takes about nine years to grow, during which time they provide a habitat for wildlife, consume carbon dioxide and create oxygen – so they are generally carbon positive. Good.

You don’t need to worry about deforestation when buying a real tree. Most Christmas trees are a horticultural crop, so growers do not fell them from pre-existing forests. Very good.

And now for the bad. Sorry. The first question that springs to mind, is, now we think about it, isn’t it a bit crazy to grow something for nine years just to cut it down and dress it up for a few weeks only to throw it away? Talk about consumer culture.

Peach Hayne Organics organic Christmas trees
Image: Peach Hayne Organics

The more every day issues, though, come with transportation and then disposal. We buy around seven million trees in the UK each year. Then, once the Christmas season is over, we send a huge number to landfill. Here, they take years to decompose and release methane, which experts say have 25 times the potency of carbon dioxide.

Potted Real Christmas Trees

Huh. But, if you’re still convinced you need a Christmas tree – and we do love them ourselves – what’s the most eco-friendly way to get one?

The best option, is to buy a potted Christmas tree that can be replanted year-after-year, as locally as possible to reduce the carbon footprint.

If potted isn’t for you, the good news is non-potted trees can be recycled into wood chippings, with a little research.

If you’re buying a non-potted Christmas tree, check your local council’s website to find out how their free recycling service operates.

Also, Forest Stewardship Council Certified trees are some of the responsibly-managed trees and often minimise pesticide use.

Organic Real Christmas Trees

Even more eco-friendly than any ol’ real Christmas tree, is an organic Christmas tree.

Peach Hayne Organics, a UK family-run organic farm in the heart of Devon, is the only farm in the UK that is registered and certified to sell Organically grown Christmas Trees.

If you live locally you can enjoy the fun of choosing your own (Christmas Market in Tiverton Pannier Market, EX16 6NH) or they deliver nationwide. 

Growing them organically means that their trees are cultivated pesticide free and with lots of TLC. Peach Hayne Organics’ tree farmer Kimberley Vick, says:

“It’s much harder to grow organic Christmas trees, you’ve got to really persevere because you can’t spray them so they are slower to grow and you have to tackle weeds that grow quicker than the actual trees themselves. So there’s a lot of labour that goes into it.” 

The benefits of organic Christmas tree farming are that there are no chemical residues in the product.

It also helps to conserve and build soil health, has a smaller carbon footprint, promotes a diverse variety of wildlife, and allows for animals like deer to enjoy snacking on the trees’ bark. 

Not, so bad after all.

Why do we have Christmas trees?

With all the fuss each year that surrounds a tree, you start to wonder where this all stemmed from… Why do we even have Christmas trees? Besides the obvious – where else would Santa leave our presents?

As it turns out, there have been many predecessors to the modern day Christmas Tree. The Romans used fir trees in their temples when honouring Saturn, the God of Agriculture. In Northern Europe, they put up Evergreen Trees during the winter solstice to keep away evil spirits and illness.

Our Christmas Tree tradition is thought to date back to the 1830s. It comes from Germany. German theologian Martin Luther is said to have started the craze after being inspired at a night’s walk through the forest and wanting to bring the outdoors in.

In 1841 Prince Albert set up a tree in Windsor Castle. In 1846 the Royal family was sketched in front of their Christmas tree. Of course, the Christmas tree trend swiftly took off. What will the royals make us covet next?

If you want to be in with a chance to win an organic Christmas tree, Peach Hayne Organics have partnered with Coombe Farm Organic for this competition (enter by 20 November).

Peach Hayne Organics organic Christmas trees
Image: Peach Hayne Organics

How sustainable is renting a Christmas tree?

Another option is to rent a real Christmas tree. Essentially, this service allows you to buy a potted sustainable Christmas tree and then send it back to be re-planted after the festive period. You can start a new family tradition and request the same one year after year. You can even name your tree, if you’re so inclined.

Not only is this a great no-fuss option, where you avoid the guilt of failing to keep your tree alive, it’s a brilliant way to cut down on your Christmas waste. 

If you’re searching for the perfect gift for lovers of the countryside, a gift voucher to Eastbook Experiences’ Farm Safari is a fun, thoughtful and family-friendly treat.

They’ll receive a guided tour around the 1,500 acres of land, where they will be shown the various wildlife they have and get a chance to get up close and personal with the pigs!

Their safaris run all year round and can be booked via their website at your convenience. 

If you’re buying an artificial tree, the general advice is that you need to use it for at least 11 years to offset the oil the plastic is made from, according to the Carbon Trust. 

However, most of us have commitment issues when it comes to fake Christmas trees. We keep them for an average of four years.

So, our general advice is that unless you’re willing to enter into a long-term committed relationship with your tree, it’s best to steer clear of fake ones. That being said, if you already have a fake tree in storage, don’t chuck it away for an upgrade. Get as much use out of it as possible.

Sustainable Christmas tree alternatives

If you’re willing to forgo the traditional tree look and branch out (pun intended), one great alternative get creative and decorate plants you already have around your home with lights and baubles.

Another popular idea is to collect branches from the park or forest and tie them together using twine.

Sustainable Christmas trees
Image: @say_no_to_waste_nz (Instagram)

This is surprisingly easy to do, is a fun day out and looks great hung off a wall. It has the added bonus of being space-saving, too.

Finally, you can buy alternative, more eco-friendly trees made from reclaimed wood online. Try shops such as Not on The High Street or Etsy.

Main image: Tomáš Malík from Pexels