The lure of salmon is easy to understand. Healthy-looking pink salmon fillets are marketed as fresh, responsibly sourced, traceable, high in omega 3 and rich in vitamin D. Smoked salmon, meanwhile, is possibly even more delectable, looking silky and steeped in heritage, described as traditional, expertly smoked and hand-carved.
We’ve been writing about the complexities of farmed salmon for many years now, and even I am tempted to question what I know to be true and believe what’s written on the packaging. Words are potent stuff.
However, the issues are being brought into sharp focus. Not least because, the Soil Association, the organisation that certifies farms to organic standards, announced they are no longer willing to allow the salmon industry to use their logo. Chief Executive of the Soil Association, Helen Browning, told me: âWe simply canât put our name to thisâ.
So, what’s the truth behind the labels? We look at how farmed salmon is produced, what the labels really mean and the environmental and welfare issues consumers should know about. But first, have you ever wondered what makes salmon flesh pink?
Why is farmed salmon pink?
Farmed salmon are denied a natural diet of krill, shrimp, and other crustaceans that makes their flesh pink. The diet salmon are fed leaves their flesh grey, so they also fed astaxanthin, a chemically synthesised pigment. Producers can choose their desired shade of flesh straight from a colour chart. As Project Slingshot puts it: “They dye them pink so they donât die grey.”
Is “Scottish salmon” farmed?
Just seeing the words “Scottish salmon” is enough for many of us to assume top quality.
There are two important points here. The first, all “Scottish salmon” is farmed (and therefore of questionable quality).
The second, many of us think buying Scottish seafood supports the economy. But, what’s not well known is that five foreign-owned firms dominate the industry and accounted for 99.5% of Scottish salmon production in 2025.
What does “responsibly sourced” salmon mean?
You are likely to be surprised that all Scottish salmon is farmed. That’s not an accident.
Scottish salmon companies won the right to drop the word âfarmedâ from the front of their packaging in 2025. Now packets say: “responsibly sourcedâ.
But, thatâs pretty irresponsible phrasing, because itâs becoming increasingly clear that salmon farming is devastating the marine environment the world over.
Also, the reason they lobbied to drop the word ‘farmed’ is because they argued it was pejorative. They also argued it wasn’t misleading to do so. But, how many of you realised that all Scottish salmon was farmed before reading this article?
What does “traceable” farmed salmon mean?
This is also misleading. Yes, often salmon can be traced back to individual farms. But, this tells you nothing about how that salmon has been farmed. For true traceability and transparency, some of the questions that need answering are: How many salmon per pen? How many died before reaching harvest? What chemicals were used? What were the salmon fed â and where did this feed come from?
Is “organic salmon” better?
When discussing the Soil Association’s organic certification of salmon farms last year with Sarah Compson, (now former) director at the Soil Association, she told me: âOrganic has the strictest standards in the UK.â
I don’t doubt that to be true. The issue is that âstrictestâ doesnât necessarily equate to âgoodâ.
This is a conclusion the Soil Association themselves seem to have reached. However, the withdrawing of their logo doesn’t mean an end to organic salmon on our shelves. Organic remains a legally recognised standard under UK and EU regulations, and accounts for around 7% of UK salmon production; certification is likely to continue in one form or another.
Interim director of charity WildFish Scotland, Andrew Graham-Stewart, insisted: âConsumers are being conned by the organic farmed salmon label, thereâs very little difference between conventional salmon and organic salmon.â
WildFish’s own analysis of sea lice numbers and mortality rates, both indicators of how salmon are being produced, found almost no difference between organic and non-organic salmon farms.
What’s “farm raised” salmon?
The word farmed might be missing from the front of Scottish salmon packaging, but âfarm raisedâ still has to be displayed on the back.
Farmed salmon are typically reared in open nets anchored near the coast in cooler seas, such as off the coast of Scotland, Norway and Iceland. From above, the farms look idyllic and consumers are sold an idea that the fish are growing in as natural conditions as possible â with the sea flowing through the pens providing currents for the salmon to swim against and washing away any uneaten food, waste and any chemical treatments.
Sea lice and disease
However, the reality is that this is intensive farming, with potentially more than 100,000 salmon reared in pens that are 35m wide. As such, the open net farms often act as breeding grounds for pests, such as sea lice, bacteria and viruses. It also means the salmon can fall prey to predators such as jellyfish.
Even on organic farms, salmon are now dying at staggering rates of more than 40% before they are harvested for food, with one organic farm reporting a production mortality of 86.8% in July 2024. This is partly due to warming seas and increasing parasites in recent years.
Waste and pollution
Salmon farming is also destroying the wider marine environment. The sea lice, bacteria and viruses flow through the open nets and have been proven to infect wild fish passing by.
Plus, waste from fish farms includes faeces and uneaten feed. This typically accumulates under the nets, feeding algae blooms and bacteria that cause a sudden drop in oxygen in the surrounding water, producing areas called âdead zonesâ, again proving harmful to marine life.
Chemicals
Even on organic farms, anti-sea lice chemicals such as deltamethrin are permitted, which are deadly to crustaceans and found to impact lobster larvae more than 30km away.
Salmon feed
Then thereâs the important issue of feed. Salmon are carnivores and feeding them requires a huge amount of fishoil and fishmeal â industrial fishing boats hoover up everything from dolphins to krill from as far away as West Africa and Antarctica to feed. This has been swallowing up fish that used to be part of local fishing industries and feed local communities for years. It’s now becoming harder to find enough fish, and fish is getting more expensive, so some farms are now feeding their salmon chicken as a cheaper protein. Just think about that for a moment.
And back to the packaging…
What does “traditional” smoked salmon mean?
Traditional doesn’t tell us a lot, really. But, it does make us feel good about a product and creates a sense of trust, however undeserving that trust is (see above).
What does “hand-carved” or “oak smoked” tells us about quality?
These do tell us about how the salmon is processed. But, it’s important to remember where the salmon came from (again, see above). To be crass, it brings to mind the phrase: “you can’t polish a turd”. Only, when it comes to salmon, apparently you can.
What to look for when buying salmon
Whether you’re buying salmon fillets or smoked salmon, look for wild. But, also, look for alternative species. It is impossible for one species to satisfy demand, we need to eat fish inline with the ratio nature provides in the wild. And if you want to read more, we’ve written about sustainable salmon and wild smoked salmon.


